BREAK IT DOWN!
It is tempting, in moments of chaos, to dismiss an administration as merely incompetent. That interpretation can feel comforting because incompetence suggests limits: mistakes can be corrected, confusion can be clarified, and disorder can eventually give way to normalcy.
But there is a more unsettling possibility. What looks like ineptitude may in fact be strategy. When leaders consistently undermine institutions, inflame division, exhaust the public, and weaken long-standing norms, it becomes harder to call the outcome accidental. At some point, the pattern is too coherent to ignore.
The better description is not failure but success on its own terms. To say an administration is incompetent assumes it is trying and failing to preserve stability, fairness, and democratic order. Yet if its real objective is to break those things—if it aims to disorient the public, discredit expertise, erode trust, and replace shared rules with raw power—then the apparent disorder is evidence not of weakness but of achievement.
The disruption is the point. Every norm shattered, every agency hollowed out, every conflict manufactured becomes proof that the project is proceeding as intended. This is why the language of incompetence can be so misleading. It frames the damage as unintended side effects rather than as central goals. A common to describe this state of affairs is, “It’s a feature, not a bug.”
The incompetence theory encourages observers to keep waiting for a correction, for adults in the room, for a return to ordinary governance. Meanwhile, the administration continues reshaping public life through attrition. People grow numb. Outrage becomes routine. Standards fall seemingly sequentially at first, then suddenly, all at once.
We have devolved into an environment in which success is measured not by effective administration in the traditional sense but by the ability to make the unacceptable seem inevitable. None of this means every action is coordinated with perfect discipline. Political movements are often messy, contradictory, and driven by ego as much as ideology. That’s how the metaphor of government as sausage-making came into common parlance.
Messiness does not cancel intent. In fact, confusion itself can be politically useful. Prior to the 2024 Election, the detractors frequently and forcefully warned of the impending Project 2025. The GOP nominee for President repeated denied having even read it, and further claimed to have no knowledge of it, whatsoever. That he had not read it…sounds plausible. Reading may be fundamental, but if one doesn’t read daily briefs…Conversely, it seems likely he was aware of the document and its intent.
It is fair to say it is incomprehensible that a regime could be both incompetent, and simultaneously capable of so swiftly and with such precision, undoing affirmative action, DEI, and the Voting Rights Act. All that has happened, literally, in a matter of months; less than 16.
When reality feels unstable, accountability becomes harder to enforce. When citizens are constantly reacting to the latest outrage, they have less energy to defend the deeper principles being dismantled underneath. Calling this dynamic incompetence therefore understates both the intelligence and the danger we face.
It mistakes destruction for clumsiness. If we want to understand what is happening, we need to judge it by outcomes, not excuses. And if the outcome is a weaker civic culture, a more cynical public, and a more fragile democratic system, then we should stop assuming the architects have failed. Rather, they are succeeding exactly as planned.
You can call them a lot of things, but by all means, scratch incompetent from the list. I shudder to contemplate our collective circumstance, by the end of this hellscape of an administration term has ended. “Don’t Call It Incompetence: More Like A Diabolical Plot!”
I’m done; holla back!
Read my blog anytime by clicking the link: http://thesphinxofcharlotte.com. Find a new post each Wednesday.
To subscribe, click on Follow in the bottom right-hand corner of my Home Page at http://thesphinxofcharlotte.com; enter your e-mail address in the designated space, and click on “Sign me up.”
Subsequent editions of “Break It Down” will be mailed to your in-box. For more detailed information on a variety of aspects related to this post, consult search engines for more information on the subject.
This post was augmented by the use of AI.
BREAK IT DOWN! 